Rouille

Des commentaires sur l'actualité internationale

14.11.04

Iraqi casualties 

From the icasualties website, I note 51 dead US soldiers in 5 days.

That means, with the current rules of thumb:

- 1500 dead Iraqi civilians in 5 days - 300 per day - the equivalent of a 9/11 EVERY DAY
- 500 wounded US soldiers - 100 a day. See the recent stories (and below) which refer to the evacuations to Germany, which fit with that number.

Left unsaid:

- how many Iraqis now hate America with their life?
- how long befroe the draft if you lose 3% of your soldiers every month (and who knows what the proportion is for frontline soldiers)??

Where's the outrage?

(At least, the media is starting to mention this. CNN.com's headline is currently Military hospital's workload doubles, with the following lead:


Battle casualties received by doctors at an American military hospital in Germany have more than doubled since the Falluja operation in Iraq began, the facility's commander told reporters Sunday. "Normally, we average 32 patients a day. In the last week, we've had an average of 70," Col. Rhonda Cornum said.

posted by Jerome a Paris  # 23:07
Comments:
2600 people (approx.) died on 9/11. I'd say thats a far cry from 300 a day dying in Iraq. (I'm not defending innocent deahts, just correcting your statistics)

The 3% statistic is also drastically skewed. You're not taking into account that we have only 25,000-30,000 soldiers over there, while we have over 1,000,000 total enlisted and reserves; so no, I don't see the draft as being likely.

I was in the army for 2 years and i have friends in Iraq now, so I share your outrage at the fact that we're over there when I feel we don't belong, but if you want to rage at least have it be a more informed rage.
 
thanks for your comment.
The reference to 9/11 was proportional to the population of each country, I am sorry I was not clear about that (Iraq population is about 1/10th of that of the US).

The 3% figure is also (hopefully) temporary, but it's still a very high rate. We'll see how it goes fairly soon, anyway.
 
Enregistrer un commentaire

Archives

mai 2004   juin 2004   juillet 2004   août 2004   octobre 2004   novembre 2004   décembre 2004   janvier 2005   septembre 2005  

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?