Rouille

Des commentaires sur l'actualité internationale

25.8.04

Has oil production peaked? 

I am still skeptical about claims that we cannot increase production in the medium term. Remember that oil prices have been pretty low in the past 18 years and that CFOs of oil companies, shareholders and outside financiers expect investments to make money at 15$/b (and to break-even at 10$/b) for an investment to be given the green light. Even with today's prices, that mindset has not changed yet - people are still expecting investments to make it with 20$/b oil or less. (there was an article about this in yesterday's FT but I cannot find the link). Wyhen this mindset changes (i.e. when these people are convinced that oil will stay above 30$/b for a bit of time, then you will suddenly see a new burst of investment.
In the short term, expect more problems: fewer wells dug last year in OPEC countries, Oil investment reduced despite record prices.


Some of the world's biggest oil-producing countries have reduced their investment in new capacity despite record oil prices. The Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries this week revealed its members drilled 6.5 per cent fewer wells in 2003, suggesting the global supply crunch and high oil prices could last longer than expected, analysts said. The numbers appear to contradict statements by Opec members that they are actively building extra capacity.



"Oil demand has been booming since quarter one 2003, offering Opec - along with rising oil prices - a clear enough signal of tightening market conditions, which the organisation seems to disregard," the Centre for Global Energy Studies (CGES), a London-based consulting firm, said recently.

"Opec has tried to get prices to stay high and now with nearly two years of very strong demand for oil we are really capacity constrained," said Leo Drollas, CGES deputy executive director and chief economist.

Opec's latest annual statistical report, published this week, shows that the number of wells completed in 2003 fell by more than 10 per cent in Kuwait, Venezuela, Qatar, Nigeria and Iran.

Opec members rarely give out complete data on the amount of money they invest in their oil industry, viewing it as a national strategic secret. Information on the number of oil wells completed per year is one of the best rough guides to future oil production as well as to overall investment trends.

Part of the explanation, in particular for Nigeria and Qatar, lies in the fact that companies are drilling fewer but more sophisticated wells. In Iran, Kuwait and Venezuela, investment has been stifled by political disagreements and leaders' eagerness to spend the additional petrodollars on other investments or the enrichment of a powerful minority. But as big consumers such as the US become more desperate for oil, the pressure is growing for countries such as Saudi Arabia and Kuwait to open their doors to international oil companies.

Mohammad Hadi Nejad Hosseinian, Iran's deputy oil minister, blamed Opec's lack of investment on past weak oil prices. "Most Opec countries have been unable to supply extra oil as a result of inadequate investment during the period when oil prices were weak," he said. "Iran expects to rely heavily on foreign investments to implement its ambitious plans [to increase oil production by nearly 2m b/d]."

Opec's capacity has remained at about 31.5m b/d since autumn 2000, though demand increased by 6m b/d and prices recovered from the Asian crisis of the late 1990s during that time, the CGES said. During that time almost three-quarters of the increased capacity needed to satisfy the extra demand came from outside Opec.

But ageing fields, a difficult investment climate in Russia and a dearth of discoveries in other parts of the world mean that consumers will not be able to rely on countries outside Opec for additional oil.

Meanwhile, US demand, which is expected to grow 4 per cent in the next four years, and that of China, forecast to increase 30 per cent, mean the world could be in for a longer period of high oil prices than expected, analysts said.

The International Energy Agency, the Paris-based industry watchdog, expects Opec capacity, excluding Iraq and Venezuela, to grow 2.1m b/d in 2005-2007. But work to achieve this does not appear to have begun.

It can take two years for countries to act on higher oil prices, but this time countries hurt by past boom and bust cycles appear to be taking longer. Opec's hesitancy means it has squandered its spare capacity, the trump card that allows it to play the role of the world's central bank of oil. It has also increased the likelihood that prices will fall only after they have climbed enough to stifle economic growth and, therefore, demand.


posted by Jerome a Paris  # 23:38
Comments:
Jérôme,

I agree with you that peak oil time has not arrived, at least for now. But I think that if OPEC's spare capacity is lost, it would be difficult to acquire it again. Yes, you can develop oil fields in the Middle East, if the host countries think it is good for them. But who is gonna build spare capacity? Saudi Arabia, a country with huge fiscal difficulties? I don't think so.

The whole of Middle East plus the Caspian is very volatile. And the volatility is going to increase. Nobody knows what's happening in the russian oil industry and Chavez victory in Venezuela means no foreign money in the local oil sector. And we 'll see where Iraq ends up.

My point is that although there remain many oilfields in the world, this doesn't mean that are open for development.

And what about the US? Until now I thought that they had a plan for stable oil markets and cheaper oil, but overestimated their power and made a huge mess unindentionally. But I have started to suspect that they don't care about stability in the oil markets.

Finally, I have a question. If everyone is convinced that the minimum price of oil will be 30$ per barrel, will production of biofuels, especially biodiesel, be profitable? (with no taxes of course)
 
The issue today is not even *spare capacity*, it is *capacity*, pure and simple. Unless this capacity is brought online, prices are going to go up, up , up...
As in any investment cycle, when people finally see that new investments are hugely profitable at the new prices, there will be a sharp increase in capacity and then a new drop in prices (say, from 80 to 40...), which in turn will allow for some spare capacity, until the cycles starts anew - unless some one smart enough invests in the capacity but does not put it online (SA?)

The issue is indeed that the investments must be done mostly in countries which do not have the money or the know-how, and must thus deal with Western companies. Many countries manage to do this to everybody's satisfaction, so why would this not be possible in Russia, SA, Iran, Mexico? It will eventually happen...and make the accompanying diplomacy lively!(Venezuela actually has quite a bit of foreign, including US, investment in its oil sector, and Chavez is not an obstacle to that).

In the meantime, if prices do keep going up, other oil or energy sources will get a boost. If oil companies start evaluating their investments with a 30$/b central hypothesis (instead of 18$/b as is still the case up to now), many marginal, technologically-complex or abandoned fields can be profitable (very deep offshore, small satellite fields of large fields, extra injection in old fields, etc). Also, other fuels become profitable.

I do not know the equivalent price level for biofuels, but 30$/b would make GTL (gasoline generated from natural gas) and oil sands profitable.
This would require prices to remain in the 30-50$ for a few years, which seems more and more likely.
 
Jérôme,

Western super majors can invest in Saudi Arabia and Venezuela. The only problem, for them, is that they have to succumb to the terms set be ARAMCO and Chavez. The bone of contention is the super profits. If they don't get them, they don't invest huge amounts of money in unstable parts of the world.

It is supposed that when oil prices go up, exploration and development of oil fields intensifies. But it doesn't happen this time. I suspect that the oil companies observe that the global economy is slowing and the chances for a global recession during the next two years are high. They have seen this game in the 80s and they didn't like it. So they are just waiting and taking huge profits. They have some major developments in the pipeline, notably in the Caspian Sea, as you have accurately described. They will bring them on line, but that's it. They don't have huge plans for other parts of the world.

We have not reached peak oil yet, but we are probably in the pre peak oil period. That's why I believe that oil prices will be extremely volatile. Note that I don't see expensive oil as the end of the world, just a gift for japanese and european capitalisms in their economic competition against the american form.

This and the previous post were writen by

Greco
 
Greco - I expected it was you!

Saudi Arabia has yet to authorise foreign investment - they have signed a few contracts, but the first round of these ended up being cancelled, and the second round is still being negotiated (and it is only on the natural gas side, where the Saudis really do not have the technical knwo-how).
Venezuela has authorised foreign investment for a long time, including recently through PSAs (you can try to google "hamaca" and "sincor" the biggest recent projects).
As I wrote in an earlier text (on which I am currently writing more, to be posted soon), the sharing of the "rent" (or the "super profits" as you call them) is nowadays always very favorable to the host country, so this is not what scares off the majors. They need to gain access to new reserves, so they can deal with greedy governments. What they want is stability once the decisions are taken, and some countries (Indonesia, Venezuela, Azerbaijan, Angola) are better at delivering this than others (Iran, SA, Russia) and thus see more investment.
Some countries see foreign investment as "foreigners stealing our wealth", even if it's the only way for them to actually access the wealth; it's a psychological/political problem onwhich economic sense (and profit) has only a muted influence.

I agree that the majors are still quite passive in view of current high oil prices. There is some natural inertia in this (they work on the basis of price hypotheses/averages for 20 or 30 years, and a couple of years of highs prices are not enough yet to change their outlook on this), and also a lack of progress in the biggest countries (reserves wise - see the names above). In accessible (from the perspective of the majors) countries, like Azerbaijan and Angola, progress has been very impressive, both in exploration and production.

From my experience of the sector, I'd say there is a lag of at least 2-3 years between oil prices and investment decisions, and we're still living with the effect of oil prices' temporary dip below 10$ in 1999. Only in the past few months have we seen major projects taking off and being financed again.
 
Hello!
Very interesting blog.
I will make sure to come back often to this blog.
If You really are interested in funds investing mutual offshore I can strongly
recommend funds investing mutual offshore
Here You can find an almost comlete directory of this subject.
 
Hi thanks for your blog, I liked it! I also have a blog/site about company investing
that covers company investing
related stuff. Please feel free to visit.
 
Hello!
You may probably be very interested to know how one can make real money on investments.
There is no initial capital needed.
You may begin to get income with a money that usually is spent
for daily food, that's 20-100 dollars.
I have been participating in one company's work for several years,
and I'm ready to share my secrets at my blog.

Please visit blog and send me private message to get the info.

P.S. I make 1000-2000 per daily now.

[url=http://theblogmoney.com] Online investment blog[/url]
 
Enregistrer un commentaire

Archives

mai 2004   juin 2004   juillet 2004   août 2004   octobre 2004   novembre 2004   décembre 2004   janvier 2005   septembre 2005  

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?